X
    Guest User
    by truepoll 6 months ago, Society & Issues

    Should Birthright Citizenship Be Ended in the U.S.?

    The Trump administration is proposing to end birthright citizenship — the current policy under the 14th Amendment that grants automatic U.S. citizenship to any child born on American soil, regardless of their parents' immigration status.

    Right now, children born in the U.S. become citizens even if their parents are undocumented (in the country illegally), temporary visa holders (like tourists, students, or foreign workers), or permanent legal residents (PLRs) — non-citizens who legally live and work in the U.S. with a green card.

    The proposed change would restrict automatic citizenship only to children born to at least one U.S. citizen. Supporters argue this would reduce immigration abuse and protect national interests. Opponents say it undermines American values and violates the Constitution. What’s your view?

    ALL

    INDIA

    MORE
    X
    • Alabama
    • Alaska
    • Arizona
    • Arkansas
    • California
    • Colorado
    • Connecticut
    • Delaware
    • District of Columbia
    • Florida
    • Georgia
    • Hawaii
    • Idaho
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Kansas
    • Kentucky
    • Louisiana
    • Lowa
    • Maine
    • Maryland
    • Massachusetts
    • Michigan
    • Michigan
    • Mississippi
    • Missouri
    • Montana
    • Nebraska
    • Nevada
    • New Hampshire
    • New Jersey
    • New Mexico
    • New York
    • North Carolina
    • North Dakota
    • Ohio
    • Oklahoma
    • Oregon
    • Pennsylvania
    • Rhode Island
    • South Carolina
    • South Dakota
    • Tennessee
    • Texas
    • Utah
    • Vermont
    • Virginia
    • Washington
    • West Virginia
    • Wisconsin
    • Wyoming
    0%
    0
    0%
    0
    0%
    0
    0%
    0
    Advertisement
    Male
    0.0%
    0
    Female
    0.0%
    0

    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs

    0
    0

    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs

    0
    0

    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants

    0
    0

    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue

    0
    0
    Advertisement

    Age Group

    Gen Z 0-24 Yrs
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    E Millennials 25-34 Yrs
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    L Millennials 35-44 Yrs
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    Gen X 45-59 Yrs
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    Boomers 60-100 Yrs
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    Advertisement

    Race

    White
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    Black
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    Asian
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    Hispanic
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    Multicultural
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    Advertisement

    Political Leaning

    Democrat
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    Republican
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    Independent
    ( 0% - 0 voters )
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — even PLRs
    0%
    Automatic citizenship should end for children of all non-citizens — except for PLRs
    0%
    All children born in the U.S. deserve citizenship — even those born to undocumented immigrants
    0%
    Not sure — I need to learn more about this issue
    Advertisement

    Like truepoll India on facebook

    Advertisement
    () START A CONVERSATION